Discussion about this post

User's avatar
mindyoshrainmd's avatar

As always a useful memo. Thank you. And some thoughts... First, I’m not sure if your use of “Hopium” was intended as a direct criticism of Simon Rosenberg…but it came off like that. Second: While I understand the peril of the binary, human beings are so often reward driven. Those who are unused to having to fight for their rights, or indeed their lives, may need the kind of optimistic encouragement Zimmer, and you, seem to disaparage in this piece. New to activism folks often want encouragement that their actions make a difference. I see that as part of the role of people like Kuo, Rosenberg and Hubbell, Solnit and HCR. Telling people that fighting fascism is necessary, and that sometimes there are wins, is essential IRL to gathering new folks to the opposition. There is a vacuum left by the absence of a strong opposition leader who can break through; we have no Churchill, FDR, Havel, Navalny or MLK Jr. at the moment. Newsom, Murphy or Pritzger have their moments, then fade. Those opposing this regime who are at what feels like the 25th mile of a marathon (even though it’s only the fifth) need to have a cheering section and a bottle of water. Having read comments on so many of the current political posts, the complexities of Zimmer’s piece are all true, as well as beautifully and clearly expressed, but may be too much for many outside the Beltline. Just imho.

Expand full comment
Richard House's avatar

The Thomas Zimmerman quote is very apt to the moment. Instant gratification amongst us is as deeply embedded as it was for the “sunshine patriots” known to Thomas Paine. Bending the arc of history is seldom accomplished but remains a hope spoken by a man, who, when he died had a 31% approval rating. Importantly, corporate media framed a laundered narrative of bothsiderism, whataboutism, to promote Trump, who would deliver their mergers despite the antitrust laws. Defeating Trump last year would not have ended the MAGA movement which has always been predominant in Americas history. And future election victory followed by appeasement and hesitancy will not end the MAGAs. In other words, it is likely that there will always be a struggle for democracy. And there always has been that struggle. Now though, it’s called a horse race, aided and abetted by a barrage of corporate media/DC insider blather.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?